Adults are more efficient in creating and transmitting novel signalling systems than children

Vera Kempe, Nicolas Gauvrit, Alison Gibson, Margaret Jamieson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Iterated language learning experiments have shown that meaningful and structured signalling systems emerge when there is pressure for signals to be both learnable and expressive. Yet such experiments have mainly been conducted with adults using language-like signals. Here we explore whether structured signalling systems can also emerge when signalling domains are unfamiliar and when the learners are children with their well-attested cognitive and pragmatic limitations. In Experiment 1, we compared iterated learning of binary auditory sequences denoting small sets of meanings in chains of adults and 5-7-year old children. Signalling systems became more learnable even though iconicity and structure did not emerge despite applying a homonymy filter designed to keep the systems expressive. When the same types of signals were used in referential communication by adult and child dyads in Experiment 2, only the adults, but not the children, were able to negotiate shared iconic and structured signals. Referential communication using their native language by 4-5-year old children in Experiment 3 showed that only interaction with adults, but not with peers resulted in informative expressions. These findings suggest that emergence and transmission of communication systems is unlikely to be driven by children, and point to the importance of cognitive maturity and pragmatic expertise of learners as well as feedback-based scaffolding of communicative effectiveness by experts during language evolution.
Original languageEnglish
Article numberlzy012
Pages (from-to)44-70
Number of pages26
JournalJournal of Language Evolution
Volume4
Issue number1
Early online date15 Feb 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

experiment
language
pragmatics
communication
maturity
dyad
communication system
learning
expertise
expert
interaction

Cite this

Kempe, Vera ; Gauvrit, Nicolas ; Gibson, Alison ; Jamieson, Margaret. / Adults are more efficient in creating and transmitting novel signalling systems than children. In: Journal of Language Evolution. 2019 ; Vol. 4, No. 1. pp. 44-70.
@article{e6394887bae4413c881119371b202a7b,
title = "Adults are more efficient in creating and transmitting novel signalling systems than children",
abstract = "Iterated language learning experiments have shown that meaningful and structured signalling systems emerge when there is pressure for signals to be both learnable and expressive. Yet such experiments have mainly been conducted with adults using language-like signals. Here we explore whether structured signalling systems can also emerge when signalling domains are unfamiliar and when the learners are children with their well-attested cognitive and pragmatic limitations. In Experiment 1, we compared iterated learning of binary auditory sequences denoting small sets of meanings in chains of adults and 5-7-year old children. Signalling systems became more learnable even though iconicity and structure did not emerge despite applying a homonymy filter designed to keep the systems expressive. When the same types of signals were used in referential communication by adult and child dyads in Experiment 2, only the adults, but not the children, were able to negotiate shared iconic and structured signals. Referential communication using their native language by 4-5-year old children in Experiment 3 showed that only interaction with adults, but not with peers resulted in informative expressions. These findings suggest that emergence and transmission of communication systems is unlikely to be driven by children, and point to the importance of cognitive maturity and pragmatic expertise of learners as well as feedback-based scaffolding of communicative effectiveness by experts during language evolution.",
author = "Vera Kempe and Nicolas Gauvrit and Alison Gibson and Margaret Jamieson",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1093/jole/lzy012",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
pages = "44--70",
journal = "Journal of Language Evolution",
issn = "2058-4571",
number = "1",

}

Adults are more efficient in creating and transmitting novel signalling systems than children. / Kempe, Vera; Gauvrit, Nicolas; Gibson, Alison; Jamieson, Margaret.

In: Journal of Language Evolution, Vol. 4, No. 1, lzy012, 2019, p. 44-70.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Adults are more efficient in creating and transmitting novel signalling systems than children

AU - Kempe, Vera

AU - Gauvrit, Nicolas

AU - Gibson, Alison

AU - Jamieson, Margaret

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Iterated language learning experiments have shown that meaningful and structured signalling systems emerge when there is pressure for signals to be both learnable and expressive. Yet such experiments have mainly been conducted with adults using language-like signals. Here we explore whether structured signalling systems can also emerge when signalling domains are unfamiliar and when the learners are children with their well-attested cognitive and pragmatic limitations. In Experiment 1, we compared iterated learning of binary auditory sequences denoting small sets of meanings in chains of adults and 5-7-year old children. Signalling systems became more learnable even though iconicity and structure did not emerge despite applying a homonymy filter designed to keep the systems expressive. When the same types of signals were used in referential communication by adult and child dyads in Experiment 2, only the adults, but not the children, were able to negotiate shared iconic and structured signals. Referential communication using their native language by 4-5-year old children in Experiment 3 showed that only interaction with adults, but not with peers resulted in informative expressions. These findings suggest that emergence and transmission of communication systems is unlikely to be driven by children, and point to the importance of cognitive maturity and pragmatic expertise of learners as well as feedback-based scaffolding of communicative effectiveness by experts during language evolution.

AB - Iterated language learning experiments have shown that meaningful and structured signalling systems emerge when there is pressure for signals to be both learnable and expressive. Yet such experiments have mainly been conducted with adults using language-like signals. Here we explore whether structured signalling systems can also emerge when signalling domains are unfamiliar and when the learners are children with their well-attested cognitive and pragmatic limitations. In Experiment 1, we compared iterated learning of binary auditory sequences denoting small sets of meanings in chains of adults and 5-7-year old children. Signalling systems became more learnable even though iconicity and structure did not emerge despite applying a homonymy filter designed to keep the systems expressive. When the same types of signals were used in referential communication by adult and child dyads in Experiment 2, only the adults, but not the children, were able to negotiate shared iconic and structured signals. Referential communication using their native language by 4-5-year old children in Experiment 3 showed that only interaction with adults, but not with peers resulted in informative expressions. These findings suggest that emergence and transmission of communication systems is unlikely to be driven by children, and point to the importance of cognitive maturity and pragmatic expertise of learners as well as feedback-based scaffolding of communicative effectiveness by experts during language evolution.

U2 - 10.1093/jole/lzy012

DO - 10.1093/jole/lzy012

M3 - Article

VL - 4

SP - 44

EP - 70

JO - Journal of Language Evolution

JF - Journal of Language Evolution

SN - 2058-4571

IS - 1

M1 - lzy012

ER -