An exploratory study of perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women

Lucy Arnot, Mhairi Thurston

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Aim/Purpose:
The aim of this study was to explore the perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women. In doing so, the study aimed to identify some of the barriers to counselling for gypsy/travellers and consider how services can respond to this.
Much has been written about the health of gypsy/travellers and access to services. However, there appears to be no research specifically addressing access to counselling or gypsy/travellers’ experiences of therapy. This study addresses this research gap by employing a qualitative approach to explore the perspectives and experiences of female gypsy/travellers.

Design/Methodology:
The study adopted an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) approach, drawing on semi-structured interviews with six gypsy/traveller women with self-reported poor mental
health.
All participants were aged in their 40s/50s and living in central Scotland, and were identified through the researcher’s role working with a charity supporting minority ethnic carers.
An idiographic approach was taken towards data analysis, identifying emerging themes and patterns across the interviews.

Results/Findings:
Analysis of the interviews revealed an overarching theme of ‘holding back’. Participants anticipated prejudice in the counselling room and reported withholding their Gypsy/Traveller
identity from counsellors. Participants also reported a fear of counselling opening up painful feelings and had found ways of ‘just getting on’ with their difficulties.

Research Limitations:
As an IPA study, the sample size was small, making it difficult to generalise the findings to all Scottish gypsy/traveller women. However, this provided rich data capturing the lived
experiences of participants.
The dual role of researcher and charity worker also posed some challenges to researcher subjectivity. However, this is also considered an asset to the research, particularly in terms of access to participants and counteracting the ‘research fatigue’ that exists in the community.

Conclusions/Implications:
This study helps counsellors and psychotherapists to understand the experiences of female gypsy/travellers and to reflect on how their practice can be more accessible to the community
and, ultimately, more culturally competent.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 19 May 2017
Event23rd Annual BACP Research Conference: Research and reflective practice for the counselling profession - The Crowne Plaza, Chester, United Kingdom
Duration: 19 May 201720 May 2017
Conference number: 23

Conference

Conference23rd Annual BACP Research Conference
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityChester
Period19/05/1720/05/17

Fingerprint

gipsy
counseling
experience
counselor
interview
psychotherapist
dual role
fatigue
prejudice
national minority
subjectivity
assets
data analysis
anxiety
worker
methodology
health

Cite this

Arnot, L., & Thurston, M. (2017). An exploratory study of perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women. Paper presented at 23rd Annual BACP Research Conference, Chester, United Kingdom.
Arnot, Lucy ; Thurston, Mhairi. / An exploratory study of perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women. Paper presented at 23rd Annual BACP Research Conference, Chester, United Kingdom.
@conference{d00849be62e84421be891e2ece76b5d4,
title = "An exploratory study of perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women",
abstract = "Aim/Purpose:The aim of this study was to explore the perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women. In doing so, the study aimed to identify some of the barriers to counselling for gypsy/travellers and consider how services can respond to this.Much has been written about the health of gypsy/travellers and access to services. However, there appears to be no research specifically addressing access to counselling or gypsy/travellers’ experiences of therapy. This study addresses this research gap by employing a qualitative approach to explore the perspectives and experiences of female gypsy/travellers.Design/Methodology:The study adopted an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) approach, drawing on semi-structured interviews with six gypsy/traveller women with self-reported poor mentalhealth.All participants were aged in their 40s/50s and living in central Scotland, and were identified through the researcher’s role working with a charity supporting minority ethnic carers.An idiographic approach was taken towards data analysis, identifying emerging themes and patterns across the interviews.Results/Findings:Analysis of the interviews revealed an overarching theme of ‘holding back’. Participants anticipated prejudice in the counselling room and reported withholding their Gypsy/Travelleridentity from counsellors. Participants also reported a fear of counselling opening up painful feelings and had found ways of ‘just getting on’ with their difficulties.Research Limitations:As an IPA study, the sample size was small, making it difficult to generalise the findings to all Scottish gypsy/traveller women. However, this provided rich data capturing the livedexperiences of participants.The dual role of researcher and charity worker also posed some challenges to researcher subjectivity. However, this is also considered an asset to the research, particularly in terms of access to participants and counteracting the ‘research fatigue’ that exists in the community.Conclusions/Implications:This study helps counsellors and psychotherapists to understand the experiences of female gypsy/travellers and to reflect on how their practice can be more accessible to the communityand, ultimately, more culturally competent.",
author = "Lucy Arnot and Mhairi Thurston",
year = "2017",
month = "5",
day = "19",
language = "English",
note = "23rd Annual BACP Research Conference : Research and reflective practice for the counselling profession ; Conference date: 19-05-2017 Through 20-05-2017",

}

Arnot, L & Thurston, M 2017, 'An exploratory study of perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women' Paper presented at 23rd Annual BACP Research Conference, Chester, United Kingdom, 19/05/17 - 20/05/17, .

An exploratory study of perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women. / Arnot, Lucy; Thurston, Mhairi.

2017. Paper presented at 23rd Annual BACP Research Conference, Chester, United Kingdom.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - An exploratory study of perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women

AU - Arnot, Lucy

AU - Thurston, Mhairi

PY - 2017/5/19

Y1 - 2017/5/19

N2 - Aim/Purpose:The aim of this study was to explore the perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women. In doing so, the study aimed to identify some of the barriers to counselling for gypsy/travellers and consider how services can respond to this.Much has been written about the health of gypsy/travellers and access to services. However, there appears to be no research specifically addressing access to counselling or gypsy/travellers’ experiences of therapy. This study addresses this research gap by employing a qualitative approach to explore the perspectives and experiences of female gypsy/travellers.Design/Methodology:The study adopted an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) approach, drawing on semi-structured interviews with six gypsy/traveller women with self-reported poor mentalhealth.All participants were aged in their 40s/50s and living in central Scotland, and were identified through the researcher’s role working with a charity supporting minority ethnic carers.An idiographic approach was taken towards data analysis, identifying emerging themes and patterns across the interviews.Results/Findings:Analysis of the interviews revealed an overarching theme of ‘holding back’. Participants anticipated prejudice in the counselling room and reported withholding their Gypsy/Travelleridentity from counsellors. Participants also reported a fear of counselling opening up painful feelings and had found ways of ‘just getting on’ with their difficulties.Research Limitations:As an IPA study, the sample size was small, making it difficult to generalise the findings to all Scottish gypsy/traveller women. However, this provided rich data capturing the livedexperiences of participants.The dual role of researcher and charity worker also posed some challenges to researcher subjectivity. However, this is also considered an asset to the research, particularly in terms of access to participants and counteracting the ‘research fatigue’ that exists in the community.Conclusions/Implications:This study helps counsellors and psychotherapists to understand the experiences of female gypsy/travellers and to reflect on how their practice can be more accessible to the communityand, ultimately, more culturally competent.

AB - Aim/Purpose:The aim of this study was to explore the perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women. In doing so, the study aimed to identify some of the barriers to counselling for gypsy/travellers and consider how services can respond to this.Much has been written about the health of gypsy/travellers and access to services. However, there appears to be no research specifically addressing access to counselling or gypsy/travellers’ experiences of therapy. This study addresses this research gap by employing a qualitative approach to explore the perspectives and experiences of female gypsy/travellers.Design/Methodology:The study adopted an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) approach, drawing on semi-structured interviews with six gypsy/traveller women with self-reported poor mentalhealth.All participants were aged in their 40s/50s and living in central Scotland, and were identified through the researcher’s role working with a charity supporting minority ethnic carers.An idiographic approach was taken towards data analysis, identifying emerging themes and patterns across the interviews.Results/Findings:Analysis of the interviews revealed an overarching theme of ‘holding back’. Participants anticipated prejudice in the counselling room and reported withholding their Gypsy/Travelleridentity from counsellors. Participants also reported a fear of counselling opening up painful feelings and had found ways of ‘just getting on’ with their difficulties.Research Limitations:As an IPA study, the sample size was small, making it difficult to generalise the findings to all Scottish gypsy/traveller women. However, this provided rich data capturing the livedexperiences of participants.The dual role of researcher and charity worker also posed some challenges to researcher subjectivity. However, this is also considered an asset to the research, particularly in terms of access to participants and counteracting the ‘research fatigue’ that exists in the community.Conclusions/Implications:This study helps counsellors and psychotherapists to understand the experiences of female gypsy/travellers and to reflect on how their practice can be more accessible to the communityand, ultimately, more culturally competent.

M3 - Paper

ER -

Arnot L, Thurston M. An exploratory study of perceptions and experiences of counselling among Scottish gypsy/traveller women. 2017. Paper presented at 23rd Annual BACP Research Conference, Chester, United Kingdom.