Descriptors and accounts of alcohol consumption: methodological issues piloted with female undergraduate drinkers in Scotland

Jan S. Gill, Marie Donaghy, Jennifer Guise, Pamela Warner

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Citations (Scopus)
7 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Excessive drinking among young women continues to attract adverse media attention and is the target of UK government-led initiatives. Reliable research on alcohol consumption is needed to inform/evaluate public health interventions. This pilot study, investigating descriptors of alcohol drinking in female Scottish undergraduate students, comprised: (i) self-completed questionnaire survey (n=95); (ii) interview plus test pouring of a ‘drink’ (n=19). Self-reports by 70% of drinkers (n=90) indicated alcohol consumption for the ‘week past’ meriting classification as ‘binge’ drinking, and 83% of this group reported drinking in this fashion at least fortnightly. However, binge-drinking may be under-estimated, since poured drinks were measured to be on average double the alcohol content for a standard drink, drinking often occurred outwith licensed premises, and respondents preferred to quantify consumption in (fractions of) bottles, rather than glasses. Qualitative analysis showed that interviewees oriented to drinking as an accountable practice but were unaware of the clinical definition of binge drinking. They defined it in terms of the effect of alcohol consumed on individual behaviour, not in absolute quantities. Given the unreliability of self-reported consumption, future health surveys and initiatives should consider ‘quantifying’ alcohol in a way more meaningful to the population of interest, in terms of effect.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)27-36
Number of pages10
JournalHealth Education Research
Volume22
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2007

Fingerprint

Scotland
alcohol consumption
Binge Drinking
Alcohol Drinking
Drinking
alcohol
Alcohols
Health Surveys
Self Report
Glass
Public Health
public health
Interviews
Students
questionnaire
interview
health
Research
Population
Group

Cite this

Gill, Jan S. ; Donaghy, Marie ; Guise, Jennifer ; Warner, Pamela. / Descriptors and accounts of alcohol consumption : methodological issues piloted with female undergraduate drinkers in Scotland. In: Health Education Research. 2007 ; Vol. 22, No. 1. pp. 27-36.
@article{f0fe889bd1ac41cdb4657ea40d393797,
title = "Descriptors and accounts of alcohol consumption: methodological issues piloted with female undergraduate drinkers in Scotland",
abstract = "Excessive drinking among young women continues to attract adverse media attention and is the target of UK government-led initiatives. Reliable research on alcohol consumption is needed to inform/evaluate public health interventions. This pilot study, investigating descriptors of alcohol drinking in female Scottish undergraduate students, comprised: (i) self-completed questionnaire survey (n=95); (ii) interview plus test pouring of a ‘drink’ (n=19). Self-reports by 70{\%} of drinkers (n=90) indicated alcohol consumption for the ‘week past’ meriting classification as ‘binge’ drinking, and 83{\%} of this group reported drinking in this fashion at least fortnightly. However, binge-drinking may be under-estimated, since poured drinks were measured to be on average double the alcohol content for a standard drink, drinking often occurred outwith licensed premises, and respondents preferred to quantify consumption in (fractions of) bottles, rather than glasses. Qualitative analysis showed that interviewees oriented to drinking as an accountable practice but were unaware of the clinical definition of binge drinking. They defined it in terms of the effect of alcohol consumed on individual behaviour, not in absolute quantities. Given the unreliability of self-reported consumption, future health surveys and initiatives should consider ‘quantifying’ alcohol in a way more meaningful to the population of interest, in terms of effect.",
author = "Gill, {Jan S.} and Marie Donaghy and Jennifer Guise and Pamela Warner",
year = "2007",
doi = "10.1093/her/cyl037",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "27--36",
journal = "Health Education Research",
issn = "0268-1153",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "1",

}

Descriptors and accounts of alcohol consumption : methodological issues piloted with female undergraduate drinkers in Scotland. / Gill, Jan S.; Donaghy, Marie; Guise, Jennifer; Warner, Pamela.

In: Health Education Research, Vol. 22, No. 1, 2007, p. 27-36.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Descriptors and accounts of alcohol consumption

T2 - methodological issues piloted with female undergraduate drinkers in Scotland

AU - Gill, Jan S.

AU - Donaghy, Marie

AU - Guise, Jennifer

AU - Warner, Pamela

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - Excessive drinking among young women continues to attract adverse media attention and is the target of UK government-led initiatives. Reliable research on alcohol consumption is needed to inform/evaluate public health interventions. This pilot study, investigating descriptors of alcohol drinking in female Scottish undergraduate students, comprised: (i) self-completed questionnaire survey (n=95); (ii) interview plus test pouring of a ‘drink’ (n=19). Self-reports by 70% of drinkers (n=90) indicated alcohol consumption for the ‘week past’ meriting classification as ‘binge’ drinking, and 83% of this group reported drinking in this fashion at least fortnightly. However, binge-drinking may be under-estimated, since poured drinks were measured to be on average double the alcohol content for a standard drink, drinking often occurred outwith licensed premises, and respondents preferred to quantify consumption in (fractions of) bottles, rather than glasses. Qualitative analysis showed that interviewees oriented to drinking as an accountable practice but were unaware of the clinical definition of binge drinking. They defined it in terms of the effect of alcohol consumed on individual behaviour, not in absolute quantities. Given the unreliability of self-reported consumption, future health surveys and initiatives should consider ‘quantifying’ alcohol in a way more meaningful to the population of interest, in terms of effect.

AB - Excessive drinking among young women continues to attract adverse media attention and is the target of UK government-led initiatives. Reliable research on alcohol consumption is needed to inform/evaluate public health interventions. This pilot study, investigating descriptors of alcohol drinking in female Scottish undergraduate students, comprised: (i) self-completed questionnaire survey (n=95); (ii) interview plus test pouring of a ‘drink’ (n=19). Self-reports by 70% of drinkers (n=90) indicated alcohol consumption for the ‘week past’ meriting classification as ‘binge’ drinking, and 83% of this group reported drinking in this fashion at least fortnightly. However, binge-drinking may be under-estimated, since poured drinks were measured to be on average double the alcohol content for a standard drink, drinking often occurred outwith licensed premises, and respondents preferred to quantify consumption in (fractions of) bottles, rather than glasses. Qualitative analysis showed that interviewees oriented to drinking as an accountable practice but were unaware of the clinical definition of binge drinking. They defined it in terms of the effect of alcohol consumed on individual behaviour, not in absolute quantities. Given the unreliability of self-reported consumption, future health surveys and initiatives should consider ‘quantifying’ alcohol in a way more meaningful to the population of interest, in terms of effect.

U2 - 10.1093/her/cyl037

DO - 10.1093/her/cyl037

M3 - Article

VL - 22

SP - 27

EP - 36

JO - Health Education Research

JF - Health Education Research

SN - 0268-1153

IS - 1

ER -