Evaluating the robustness of large species tree combined drainage system for managing stormwater in urban areas

Alison Duffy, Juliette O'Keeffe, Elizabeth Prosser, Kate Heal, Dean Bowie, James Dalrymple

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePoster

    Abstract

    Introduction
    Large trees provide financial and environmental benefits, whilst also contributing to the well-being of 80% of urban populations (Armour, et al, 2012). In terms of climate change, planting large species trees will regulate microclimates, filter rainwater, attenuate noise, improve air quality and sequester carbon (UNEA, 2011). According to Warwick and Charlesworth (2013) one urban tree sequesters approximately 100kg of carbon per year. Armosa et al (2013) claim that tree pits reduce runoff by 60% when compared to asphalt. Sustainable drainage systems (SUDS) are common in Scotland. However, it is argued that many have not resulted in quality of place (TDAG, 2014). The general position of the Scottish Environment Agency is that whilst SUDS are required for new developments and redevelopments, the retrofit of proprietary SUDS is not recommended unless the functions of treatment, infiltration and flow attenuation are fulfilled.

    A monitoring programme in collaboration with Dundee City Council for a novel SUDS proprietary product which is combined with a large species tree pit has been in place since 2012. The system, retrofitted to a car park and discharging to a combined sewer system, has been engineered to provide a healthy environment for tree root growth and prevent pavement damage (Lucke et al 2011). Benefits over and above those stated above include: stormwater attenuation which increases over time as the tree matures; downstream SUDS footprint reduction; reduced pumping and treatment costs in combined sewer areas; and hydrocarbon removal. The system consists of various underground components; of note are the SUDS troughs that act as a storage reservoir during times of drought. The top section of the troughs is lined with a semi-impermeable membrane and filled with Leca (expanded clay balls) to filter runoff before entering the system.

    Research Undertaken
    The study investigates the robustness of the system and aims to validate that it is fit for purpose. The paper will discuss retrofit limitations, initial monitoring results for water quality, tree growth and vigour. The system has been adapted from sheet to piped flow in order to collect car park runoff entering the system and treated runoff leaving the system. Initially, grab sampling was used to collect water samples but limitations of this technique (reactive sampling following rainfall) meant that it was difficult to respond quickly to storm events. Flow loggers and automatic samplers are now installed at the inlet and outlet. Parameters analysed include: Heavy metals (Arsenic, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper, Lead, Nickel, Zinc); Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons; pH; BOD, Suspended Solids; Conductivity; Chloride; Phosphate; Nitrogen. A control tree has also been planted in nearby public open space to enable regular health monitoring for both trees by recording tree heights, crowns and girth sizes.

    Results
    To date average concentrations for all parameters except chromium discharged from the system are within Environmental Quality Standards for Priority and Dangerous Substances (Directive 2006/11/EC). On average BOD is reduced by 40%, P 16%, N 76%, TPH 100%, Arsenic 100%, Copper 26%, Nickel 66%, Lead 31% and Zinc 10%. Cadmium concentration has always recorded below the limit of detection. Chromium concentration increases on average by 50% which exceeds the threshold by 42%. A one off analysis of settled sediments in the trough water, the membrane and Leca was undertaken in July 2014 to give an indication of uptake of pollutants in these materials / components. From the results it is evident that the Leca and membrane are retaining pollutants associated with sediments from entering the system – the filter media more so than the clay balls. Sediments that are settling on the base of the trough are also retaining pollutants. It is too early to comment on tree health but measurements taken to date initially indicate that the tree in the tree pit is growing at a faster rate than the control tree. System hydraulics has still to be analysed in detail to ascertain attenuation performance.

    Conclusions and Recommendations
    From a water quality perspective, overall the system is performing well and satisfies EU criteria for water quality standards apart from chromium. This is a brownfield site that is located where a textile mill used to operate and there may be historical influences to consider. There is the likelihood that legacy contaminants such as chromium remain in the environment as this used to be a key component for the dyeing process. The next steps to validate the system are to quantify attenuation performance and continue water quality and health monitoring.
    Original languageEnglish
    Number of pages2
    Publication statusPublished - 2015
    EventWorld Water Congress XV - Edinburgh, United Kingdom
    Duration: 25 May 201529 May 2015
    Conference number: 15
    http://www.iwra.org/congress/2015/

    Conference

    ConferenceWorld Water Congress XV
    CountryUnited Kingdom
    CityEdinburgh
    Period25/05/1529/05/15
    Internet address

    Fingerprint

    stormwater
    urban area
    chromium
    trough
    runoff
    water quality
    health monitoring
    pollutant
    drainage system
    membrane
    filter
    arsenic
    nickel
    cadmium
    zinc
    brownfield site
    sediment
    copper
    clay
    public space

    Cite this

    Duffy, A., O'Keeffe, J., Prosser, E., Heal, K., Bowie, D., & Dalrymple, J. (2015). Evaluating the robustness of large species tree combined drainage system for managing stormwater in urban areas. Poster session presented at World Water Congress XV, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
    Duffy, Alison ; O'Keeffe, Juliette ; Prosser, Elizabeth ; Heal, Kate ; Bowie, Dean ; Dalrymple, James. / Evaluating the robustness of large species tree combined drainage system for managing stormwater in urban areas. Poster session presented at World Water Congress XV, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.2 p.
    @conference{40821aa8f4b54eaa9e69b9155f23e933,
    title = "Evaluating the robustness of large species tree combined drainage system for managing stormwater in urban areas",
    abstract = "IntroductionLarge trees provide financial and environmental benefits, whilst also contributing to the well-being of 80{\%} of urban populations (Armour, et al, 2012). In terms of climate change, planting large species trees will regulate microclimates, filter rainwater, attenuate noise, improve air quality and sequester carbon (UNEA, 2011). According to Warwick and Charlesworth (2013) one urban tree sequesters approximately 100kg of carbon per year. Armosa et al (2013) claim that tree pits reduce runoff by 60{\%} when compared to asphalt. Sustainable drainage systems (SUDS) are common in Scotland. However, it is argued that many have not resulted in quality of place (TDAG, 2014). The general position of the Scottish Environment Agency is that whilst SUDS are required for new developments and redevelopments, the retrofit of proprietary SUDS is not recommended unless the functions of treatment, infiltration and flow attenuation are fulfilled. A monitoring programme in collaboration with Dundee City Council for a novel SUDS proprietary product which is combined with a large species tree pit has been in place since 2012. The system, retrofitted to a car park and discharging to a combined sewer system, has been engineered to provide a healthy environment for tree root growth and prevent pavement damage (Lucke et al 2011). Benefits over and above those stated above include: stormwater attenuation which increases over time as the tree matures; downstream SUDS footprint reduction; reduced pumping and treatment costs in combined sewer areas; and hydrocarbon removal. The system consists of various underground components; of note are the SUDS troughs that act as a storage reservoir during times of drought. The top section of the troughs is lined with a semi-impermeable membrane and filled with Leca (expanded clay balls) to filter runoff before entering the system. Research UndertakenThe study investigates the robustness of the system and aims to validate that it is fit for purpose. The paper will discuss retrofit limitations, initial monitoring results for water quality, tree growth and vigour. The system has been adapted from sheet to piped flow in order to collect car park runoff entering the system and treated runoff leaving the system. Initially, grab sampling was used to collect water samples but limitations of this technique (reactive sampling following rainfall) meant that it was difficult to respond quickly to storm events. Flow loggers and automatic samplers are now installed at the inlet and outlet. Parameters analysed include: Heavy metals (Arsenic, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper, Lead, Nickel, Zinc); Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons; pH; BOD, Suspended Solids; Conductivity; Chloride; Phosphate; Nitrogen. A control tree has also been planted in nearby public open space to enable regular health monitoring for both trees by recording tree heights, crowns and girth sizes. ResultsTo date average concentrations for all parameters except chromium discharged from the system are within Environmental Quality Standards for Priority and Dangerous Substances (Directive 2006/11/EC). On average BOD is reduced by 40{\%}, P 16{\%}, N 76{\%}, TPH 100{\%}, Arsenic 100{\%}, Copper 26{\%}, Nickel 66{\%}, Lead 31{\%} and Zinc 10{\%}. Cadmium concentration has always recorded below the limit of detection. Chromium concentration increases on average by 50{\%} which exceeds the threshold by 42{\%}. A one off analysis of settled sediments in the trough water, the membrane and Leca was undertaken in July 2014 to give an indication of uptake of pollutants in these materials / components. From the results it is evident that the Leca and membrane are retaining pollutants associated with sediments from entering the system – the filter media more so than the clay balls. Sediments that are settling on the base of the trough are also retaining pollutants. It is too early to comment on tree health but measurements taken to date initially indicate that the tree in the tree pit is growing at a faster rate than the control tree. System hydraulics has still to be analysed in detail to ascertain attenuation performance. Conclusions and RecommendationsFrom a water quality perspective, overall the system is performing well and satisfies EU criteria for water quality standards apart from chromium. This is a brownfield site that is located where a textile mill used to operate and there may be historical influences to consider. There is the likelihood that legacy contaminants such as chromium remain in the environment as this used to be a key component for the dyeing process. The next steps to validate the system are to quantify attenuation performance and continue water quality and health monitoring.",
    author = "Alison Duffy and Juliette O'Keeffe and Elizabeth Prosser and Kate Heal and Dean Bowie and James Dalrymple",
    year = "2015",
    language = "English",
    note = "World Water Congress XV ; Conference date: 25-05-2015 Through 29-05-2015",
    url = "http://www.iwra.org/congress/2015/",

    }

    Duffy, A, O'Keeffe, J, Prosser, E, Heal, K, Bowie, D & Dalrymple, J 2015, 'Evaluating the robustness of large species tree combined drainage system for managing stormwater in urban areas' World Water Congress XV, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 25/05/15 - 29/05/15, .

    Evaluating the robustness of large species tree combined drainage system for managing stormwater in urban areas. / Duffy, Alison; O'Keeffe, Juliette; Prosser, Elizabeth; Heal, Kate; Bowie, Dean; Dalrymple, James.

    2015. Poster session presented at World Water Congress XV, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePoster

    TY - CONF

    T1 - Evaluating the robustness of large species tree combined drainage system for managing stormwater in urban areas

    AU - Duffy, Alison

    AU - O'Keeffe, Juliette

    AU - Prosser, Elizabeth

    AU - Heal, Kate

    AU - Bowie, Dean

    AU - Dalrymple, James

    PY - 2015

    Y1 - 2015

    N2 - IntroductionLarge trees provide financial and environmental benefits, whilst also contributing to the well-being of 80% of urban populations (Armour, et al, 2012). In terms of climate change, planting large species trees will regulate microclimates, filter rainwater, attenuate noise, improve air quality and sequester carbon (UNEA, 2011). According to Warwick and Charlesworth (2013) one urban tree sequesters approximately 100kg of carbon per year. Armosa et al (2013) claim that tree pits reduce runoff by 60% when compared to asphalt. Sustainable drainage systems (SUDS) are common in Scotland. However, it is argued that many have not resulted in quality of place (TDAG, 2014). The general position of the Scottish Environment Agency is that whilst SUDS are required for new developments and redevelopments, the retrofit of proprietary SUDS is not recommended unless the functions of treatment, infiltration and flow attenuation are fulfilled. A monitoring programme in collaboration with Dundee City Council for a novel SUDS proprietary product which is combined with a large species tree pit has been in place since 2012. The system, retrofitted to a car park and discharging to a combined sewer system, has been engineered to provide a healthy environment for tree root growth and prevent pavement damage (Lucke et al 2011). Benefits over and above those stated above include: stormwater attenuation which increases over time as the tree matures; downstream SUDS footprint reduction; reduced pumping and treatment costs in combined sewer areas; and hydrocarbon removal. The system consists of various underground components; of note are the SUDS troughs that act as a storage reservoir during times of drought. The top section of the troughs is lined with a semi-impermeable membrane and filled with Leca (expanded clay balls) to filter runoff before entering the system. Research UndertakenThe study investigates the robustness of the system and aims to validate that it is fit for purpose. The paper will discuss retrofit limitations, initial monitoring results for water quality, tree growth and vigour. The system has been adapted from sheet to piped flow in order to collect car park runoff entering the system and treated runoff leaving the system. Initially, grab sampling was used to collect water samples but limitations of this technique (reactive sampling following rainfall) meant that it was difficult to respond quickly to storm events. Flow loggers and automatic samplers are now installed at the inlet and outlet. Parameters analysed include: Heavy metals (Arsenic, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper, Lead, Nickel, Zinc); Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons; pH; BOD, Suspended Solids; Conductivity; Chloride; Phosphate; Nitrogen. A control tree has also been planted in nearby public open space to enable regular health monitoring for both trees by recording tree heights, crowns and girth sizes. ResultsTo date average concentrations for all parameters except chromium discharged from the system are within Environmental Quality Standards for Priority and Dangerous Substances (Directive 2006/11/EC). On average BOD is reduced by 40%, P 16%, N 76%, TPH 100%, Arsenic 100%, Copper 26%, Nickel 66%, Lead 31% and Zinc 10%. Cadmium concentration has always recorded below the limit of detection. Chromium concentration increases on average by 50% which exceeds the threshold by 42%. A one off analysis of settled sediments in the trough water, the membrane and Leca was undertaken in July 2014 to give an indication of uptake of pollutants in these materials / components. From the results it is evident that the Leca and membrane are retaining pollutants associated with sediments from entering the system – the filter media more so than the clay balls. Sediments that are settling on the base of the trough are also retaining pollutants. It is too early to comment on tree health but measurements taken to date initially indicate that the tree in the tree pit is growing at a faster rate than the control tree. System hydraulics has still to be analysed in detail to ascertain attenuation performance. Conclusions and RecommendationsFrom a water quality perspective, overall the system is performing well and satisfies EU criteria for water quality standards apart from chromium. This is a brownfield site that is located where a textile mill used to operate and there may be historical influences to consider. There is the likelihood that legacy contaminants such as chromium remain in the environment as this used to be a key component for the dyeing process. The next steps to validate the system are to quantify attenuation performance and continue water quality and health monitoring.

    AB - IntroductionLarge trees provide financial and environmental benefits, whilst also contributing to the well-being of 80% of urban populations (Armour, et al, 2012). In terms of climate change, planting large species trees will regulate microclimates, filter rainwater, attenuate noise, improve air quality and sequester carbon (UNEA, 2011). According to Warwick and Charlesworth (2013) one urban tree sequesters approximately 100kg of carbon per year. Armosa et al (2013) claim that tree pits reduce runoff by 60% when compared to asphalt. Sustainable drainage systems (SUDS) are common in Scotland. However, it is argued that many have not resulted in quality of place (TDAG, 2014). The general position of the Scottish Environment Agency is that whilst SUDS are required for new developments and redevelopments, the retrofit of proprietary SUDS is not recommended unless the functions of treatment, infiltration and flow attenuation are fulfilled. A monitoring programme in collaboration with Dundee City Council for a novel SUDS proprietary product which is combined with a large species tree pit has been in place since 2012. The system, retrofitted to a car park and discharging to a combined sewer system, has been engineered to provide a healthy environment for tree root growth and prevent pavement damage (Lucke et al 2011). Benefits over and above those stated above include: stormwater attenuation which increases over time as the tree matures; downstream SUDS footprint reduction; reduced pumping and treatment costs in combined sewer areas; and hydrocarbon removal. The system consists of various underground components; of note are the SUDS troughs that act as a storage reservoir during times of drought. The top section of the troughs is lined with a semi-impermeable membrane and filled with Leca (expanded clay balls) to filter runoff before entering the system. Research UndertakenThe study investigates the robustness of the system and aims to validate that it is fit for purpose. The paper will discuss retrofit limitations, initial monitoring results for water quality, tree growth and vigour. The system has been adapted from sheet to piped flow in order to collect car park runoff entering the system and treated runoff leaving the system. Initially, grab sampling was used to collect water samples but limitations of this technique (reactive sampling following rainfall) meant that it was difficult to respond quickly to storm events. Flow loggers and automatic samplers are now installed at the inlet and outlet. Parameters analysed include: Heavy metals (Arsenic, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper, Lead, Nickel, Zinc); Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons; pH; BOD, Suspended Solids; Conductivity; Chloride; Phosphate; Nitrogen. A control tree has also been planted in nearby public open space to enable regular health monitoring for both trees by recording tree heights, crowns and girth sizes. ResultsTo date average concentrations for all parameters except chromium discharged from the system are within Environmental Quality Standards for Priority and Dangerous Substances (Directive 2006/11/EC). On average BOD is reduced by 40%, P 16%, N 76%, TPH 100%, Arsenic 100%, Copper 26%, Nickel 66%, Lead 31% and Zinc 10%. Cadmium concentration has always recorded below the limit of detection. Chromium concentration increases on average by 50% which exceeds the threshold by 42%. A one off analysis of settled sediments in the trough water, the membrane and Leca was undertaken in July 2014 to give an indication of uptake of pollutants in these materials / components. From the results it is evident that the Leca and membrane are retaining pollutants associated with sediments from entering the system – the filter media more so than the clay balls. Sediments that are settling on the base of the trough are also retaining pollutants. It is too early to comment on tree health but measurements taken to date initially indicate that the tree in the tree pit is growing at a faster rate than the control tree. System hydraulics has still to be analysed in detail to ascertain attenuation performance. Conclusions and RecommendationsFrom a water quality perspective, overall the system is performing well and satisfies EU criteria for water quality standards apart from chromium. This is a brownfield site that is located where a textile mill used to operate and there may be historical influences to consider. There is the likelihood that legacy contaminants such as chromium remain in the environment as this used to be a key component for the dyeing process. The next steps to validate the system are to quantify attenuation performance and continue water quality and health monitoring.

    M3 - Poster

    ER -

    Duffy A, O'Keeffe J, Prosser E, Heal K, Bowie D, Dalrymple J. Evaluating the robustness of large species tree combined drainage system for managing stormwater in urban areas. 2015. Poster session presented at World Water Congress XV, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.