Gender relations in higher education: exploring lecturers' perceptions of student evaluations of teaching

Lloyd Carson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Quantitative evidence suggests that higher education students may exhibit gender bias against women when evaluating the teaching of male and female faculty. Qualitative research in this area has been concerned with the broader context of institutional sexism in academia, which has been represented as a pervasive and depressing influence on women lecturers. Relatively little research has investigated university teachers' specific views about student perceptions and behaviour. This study explored this issue qualitatively in a group of British academics. While most of the female academics represented students as having prejudiced views about them, the prevailing understanding in the literature of women university staff as demoralized, alienated and experiencing tension between their occupational and feminine selves was not confirmed. Rather, women appeared entirely confident in their identities as conscientious teachers, a circumstance which related empirically (and possibly theoretically) to an almost unanimous derogation of their male colleagues. No body of literature about male lecturers' views of sexism exists: this study suggested that they contrast markedly with those of their female colleagues. Problematic aspects of women's apparent assiduity about teaching are discussed, as is the other principal area of concern raised by the study, namely the extensive areas of disagreement in outlook between the female and male respondents.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)337-358
Number of pages22
JournalResearch Papers in Education
Volume16
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 2001

Fingerprint

university teacher
woman
student
sexism
perception
education
academic (female)
women's university
measurement method
gender relations
qualitative research
academic
teaching staff
staff
identity
trend
teacher
understanding
behavior
influence exertion

Cite this

Carson, Lloyd / Gender relations in higher education : exploring lecturers' perceptions of student evaluations of teaching.

In: Research Papers in Education, Vol. 16, No. 4, 12.2001, p. 337-358.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9ae174d5af0144abb91b8c186f89e567,
title = "Gender relations in higher education: exploring lecturers' perceptions of student evaluations of teaching",
abstract = "Quantitative evidence suggests that higher education students may exhibit gender bias against women when evaluating the teaching of male and female faculty. Qualitative research in this area has been concerned with the broader context of institutional sexism in academia, which has been represented as a pervasive and depressing influence on women lecturers. Relatively little research has investigated university teachers' specific views about student perceptions and behaviour. This study explored this issue qualitatively in a group of British academics. While most of the female academics represented students as having prejudiced views about them, the prevailing understanding in the literature of women university staff as demoralized, alienated and experiencing tension between their occupational and feminine selves was not confirmed. Rather, women appeared entirely confident in their identities as conscientious teachers, a circumstance which related empirically (and possibly theoretically) to an almost unanimous derogation of their male colleagues. No body of literature about male lecturers' views of sexism exists: this study suggested that they contrast markedly with those of their female colleagues. Problematic aspects of women's apparent assiduity about teaching are discussed, as is the other principal area of concern raised by the study, namely the extensive areas of disagreement in outlook between the female and male respondents.",
author = "Lloyd Carson",
year = "2001",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1080/02671520152731990",
volume = "16",
pages = "337--358",
journal = "Research Papers in Education",
issn = "0267-1522",
publisher = "N F E R Nelson Publishing Limited",
number = "4",

}

Gender relations in higher education : exploring lecturers' perceptions of student evaluations of teaching. / Carson, Lloyd.

In: Research Papers in Education, Vol. 16, No. 4, 12.2001, p. 337-358.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Gender relations in higher education

T2 - Research Papers in Education

AU - Carson,Lloyd

PY - 2001/12

Y1 - 2001/12

N2 - Quantitative evidence suggests that higher education students may exhibit gender bias against women when evaluating the teaching of male and female faculty. Qualitative research in this area has been concerned with the broader context of institutional sexism in academia, which has been represented as a pervasive and depressing influence on women lecturers. Relatively little research has investigated university teachers' specific views about student perceptions and behaviour. This study explored this issue qualitatively in a group of British academics. While most of the female academics represented students as having prejudiced views about them, the prevailing understanding in the literature of women university staff as demoralized, alienated and experiencing tension between their occupational and feminine selves was not confirmed. Rather, women appeared entirely confident in their identities as conscientious teachers, a circumstance which related empirically (and possibly theoretically) to an almost unanimous derogation of their male colleagues. No body of literature about male lecturers' views of sexism exists: this study suggested that they contrast markedly with those of their female colleagues. Problematic aspects of women's apparent assiduity about teaching are discussed, as is the other principal area of concern raised by the study, namely the extensive areas of disagreement in outlook between the female and male respondents.

AB - Quantitative evidence suggests that higher education students may exhibit gender bias against women when evaluating the teaching of male and female faculty. Qualitative research in this area has been concerned with the broader context of institutional sexism in academia, which has been represented as a pervasive and depressing influence on women lecturers. Relatively little research has investigated university teachers' specific views about student perceptions and behaviour. This study explored this issue qualitatively in a group of British academics. While most of the female academics represented students as having prejudiced views about them, the prevailing understanding in the literature of women university staff as demoralized, alienated and experiencing tension between their occupational and feminine selves was not confirmed. Rather, women appeared entirely confident in their identities as conscientious teachers, a circumstance which related empirically (and possibly theoretically) to an almost unanimous derogation of their male colleagues. No body of literature about male lecturers' views of sexism exists: this study suggested that they contrast markedly with those of their female colleagues. Problematic aspects of women's apparent assiduity about teaching are discussed, as is the other principal area of concern raised by the study, namely the extensive areas of disagreement in outlook between the female and male respondents.

U2 - 10.1080/02671520152731990

DO - 10.1080/02671520152731990

M3 - Article

VL - 16

SP - 337

EP - 358

JO - Research Papers in Education

JF - Research Papers in Education

SN - 0267-1522

IS - 4

ER -