Monocular rivalry exhibits three hallmarks of binocular rivalry: evidence for common processes

Robert P. O’Shea, Amanda Parker, David J. La Rooy, David Alais

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  • 20 Citations

Abstract

Binocular rivalry occurs when different images are presented one to each eye: the images are visible only alternately. Monocular rivalry occurs when different images are presented both to the same eye: the clarity of the images fluctuates alternately. Could both sorts of rivalry reflect the operation of a general visual mechanism for dealing with perceptual ambiguity? We report four experiments showing similarities between the two phenomena. First, we show that monocular rivalry can occur with complex images, as with binocular rivalry, and that the two phenomena are affected similarly by the size (Experiment 1) and colour (Experiment 2) of the images. Second, we show that the distribution of dominance periods during monocular rivalry has a gamma shape and is stochastic (Experiment 3). Third, we show that during periods of monocular-rivalry suppression, the threshold to detect a probe (a contrast pulse to the suppressed stimulus) is raised compared with during periods of dominance (Experiment 4). The threshold elevation is much weaker than during binocular rivalry, consistent with monocular rivalry’s weak appearance. We discuss other similarities between monocular and binocular rivalry, and also some differences, concluding that part of the processing underlying both phenomena is a general visual mechanism for dealing with perceptual ambiguity.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)671-681
Number of pages11
JournalVision Research
Volume49
Issue number7
DOIs
StatePublished - 29 Apr 2009

Fingerprint

Color

Cite this

O’Shea, Robert P.; Parker, Amanda; La Rooy, David J.; Alais, David / Monocular rivalry exhibits three hallmarks of binocular rivalry : evidence for common processes.

In: Vision Research, Vol. 49, No. 7, 29.04.2009, p. 671-681.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{d245e471d38645d3a669963064cbeb8b,
title = "Monocular rivalry exhibits three hallmarks of binocular rivalry: evidence for common processes",
abstract = "Binocular rivalry occurs when different images are presented one to each eye: the images are visible only alternately. Monocular rivalry occurs when different images are presented both to the same eye: the clarity of the images fluctuates alternately. Could both sorts of rivalry reflect the operation of a general visual mechanism for dealing with perceptual ambiguity? We report four experiments showing similarities between the two phenomena. First, we show that monocular rivalry can occur with complex images, as with binocular rivalry, and that the two phenomena are affected similarly by the size (Experiment 1) and colour (Experiment 2) of the images. Second, we show that the distribution of dominance periods during monocular rivalry has a gamma shape and is stochastic (Experiment 3). Third, we show that during periods of monocular-rivalry suppression, the threshold to detect a probe (a contrast pulse to the suppressed stimulus) is raised compared with during periods of dominance (Experiment 4). The threshold elevation is much weaker than during binocular rivalry, consistent with monocular rivalry’s weak appearance. We discuss other similarities between monocular and binocular rivalry, and also some differences, concluding that part of the processing underlying both phenomena is a general visual mechanism for dealing with perceptual ambiguity.",
author = "O’Shea, {Robert P.} and Amanda Parker and {La Rooy}, {David J.} and David Alais",
year = "2009",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1016/j.visres.2009.01.020",
volume = "49",
pages = "671--681",
journal = "Vision Research",
issn = "0042-6989",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",
number = "7",

}

O’Shea, RP, Parker, A, La Rooy, DJ & Alais, D 2009, 'Monocular rivalry exhibits three hallmarks of binocular rivalry: evidence for common processes' Vision Research, vol 49, no. 7, pp. 671-681. DOI: 10.1016/j.visres.2009.01.020

Monocular rivalry exhibits three hallmarks of binocular rivalry : evidence for common processes. / O’Shea, Robert P.; Parker, Amanda; La Rooy, David J.; Alais, David.

In: Vision Research, Vol. 49, No. 7, 29.04.2009, p. 671-681.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Monocular rivalry exhibits three hallmarks of binocular rivalry

T2 - Vision Research

AU - O’Shea,Robert P.

AU - Parker,Amanda

AU - La Rooy,David J.

AU - Alais,David

PY - 2009/4/29

Y1 - 2009/4/29

N2 - Binocular rivalry occurs when different images are presented one to each eye: the images are visible only alternately. Monocular rivalry occurs when different images are presented both to the same eye: the clarity of the images fluctuates alternately. Could both sorts of rivalry reflect the operation of a general visual mechanism for dealing with perceptual ambiguity? We report four experiments showing similarities between the two phenomena. First, we show that monocular rivalry can occur with complex images, as with binocular rivalry, and that the two phenomena are affected similarly by the size (Experiment 1) and colour (Experiment 2) of the images. Second, we show that the distribution of dominance periods during monocular rivalry has a gamma shape and is stochastic (Experiment 3). Third, we show that during periods of monocular-rivalry suppression, the threshold to detect a probe (a contrast pulse to the suppressed stimulus) is raised compared with during periods of dominance (Experiment 4). The threshold elevation is much weaker than during binocular rivalry, consistent with monocular rivalry’s weak appearance. We discuss other similarities between monocular and binocular rivalry, and also some differences, concluding that part of the processing underlying both phenomena is a general visual mechanism for dealing with perceptual ambiguity.

AB - Binocular rivalry occurs when different images are presented one to each eye: the images are visible only alternately. Monocular rivalry occurs when different images are presented both to the same eye: the clarity of the images fluctuates alternately. Could both sorts of rivalry reflect the operation of a general visual mechanism for dealing with perceptual ambiguity? We report four experiments showing similarities between the two phenomena. First, we show that monocular rivalry can occur with complex images, as with binocular rivalry, and that the two phenomena are affected similarly by the size (Experiment 1) and colour (Experiment 2) of the images. Second, we show that the distribution of dominance periods during monocular rivalry has a gamma shape and is stochastic (Experiment 3). Third, we show that during periods of monocular-rivalry suppression, the threshold to detect a probe (a contrast pulse to the suppressed stimulus) is raised compared with during periods of dominance (Experiment 4). The threshold elevation is much weaker than during binocular rivalry, consistent with monocular rivalry’s weak appearance. We discuss other similarities between monocular and binocular rivalry, and also some differences, concluding that part of the processing underlying both phenomena is a general visual mechanism for dealing with perceptual ambiguity.

U2 - 10.1016/j.visres.2009.01.020

DO - 10.1016/j.visres.2009.01.020

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 671

EP - 681

JO - Vision Research

JF - Vision Research

SN - 0042-6989

IS - 7

ER -

O’Shea RP, Parker A, La Rooy DJ, Alais D. Monocular rivalry exhibits three hallmarks of binocular rivalry: evidence for common processes. Vision Research. 2009 Apr 29;49(7):671-681. Available from, DOI: 10.1016/j.visres.2009.01.020