Practice research networks: promises, pitfalls and potential

Joe Armstrong, Amanda Hawkins, Mhairi Thurston, Alison Hood

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

A critical issue facing the counselling and psychotherapy profession at present concerns the question of how to build a strong and externally-credible evidence base for its effectiveness. There is an emerging view that unless we address this question, counselling and psychotherapy approaches may be sidelined in favour of therapies with a much stronger base of research findings that support their effectiveness. Ultimately, a lack of an evidence base for the effectiveness of counselling and psychotherapy approaches may mean that they struggle to survive and be recognised as credible interventions for mental distress, particularly within public sector settings.

But how can we go about building this evidence base? There is much debate about the value and relevance of different types of research (eg qualitative versus quantitative) in relation to building such an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy. However, perhaps a much more pressing issue concerns how we engage members of the counselling and psychotherapy community in research. Especially, when there is good evidence to show that findings from research have only limited influence on the everyday practice of counsellors and psychotherapists - often because it does not adequately address the issues they encounter in their practice. One approach to engaging practitioners in research that has been employed successfully is the establishment of ‘practice research networks'. Essentially, a practice research network (PRN) provides a structure within which researchers, practitioners and other relevant stakeholders can collaborate on collecting data and carrying out research studies.

This workshop will present the work of two PRNs at different stages of development as case studies around which to engage in reflection and discussion regarding the challenges and potential of the practice research network as a means of promoting and developing research that might contribute to the establishment of an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy. Dr Joe Armstrong from the University of Abertay will present the work of the recently established Scottish Voluntary Sector Counselling Practice Research Network and Amanda Hawkins, Senior Manager RNIB (Chair of BACP) and Mhairi Thurston, University of Abertay will present the work of the Vision Impairment Network for Counselling and Emotional Support (VINCE). The workshop will also provide opportunities for discussion in small groups and contributions from participants in larger plenary sessions.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 10 May 2012
EventBACP's 18th Annual Research conference : Understanding counselling and psychotherapy: preferences, process and outcomes - Boxburghe Hotel, Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Duration: 10 May 201212 May 2012
Conference number: 18

Conference

ConferenceBACP's 18th Annual Research conference
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityEdinburgh
Period10/05/1212/05/12

Fingerprint

research practice
counseling
psychotherapy
evidence
psychotherapist
counselor
small group
public sector
profession
stakeholder
manager
lack
present
community
Values

Cite this

Armstrong, J., Hawkins, A., Thurston, M., & Hood, A. (2012). Practice research networks: promises, pitfalls and potential. Paper presented at BACP's 18th Annual Research conference , Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
Armstrong, Joe ; Hawkins, Amanda ; Thurston, Mhairi ; Hood, Alison. / Practice research networks : promises, pitfalls and potential. Paper presented at BACP's 18th Annual Research conference , Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
@conference{daf4341beb1d41568ac7262f316daa19,
title = "Practice research networks: promises, pitfalls and potential",
abstract = "A critical issue facing the counselling and psychotherapy profession at present concerns the question of how to build a strong and externally-credible evidence base for its effectiveness. There is an emerging view that unless we address this question, counselling and psychotherapy approaches may be sidelined in favour of therapies with a much stronger base of research findings that support their effectiveness. Ultimately, a lack of an evidence base for the effectiveness of counselling and psychotherapy approaches may mean that they struggle to survive and be recognised as credible interventions for mental distress, particularly within public sector settings.But how can we go about building this evidence base? There is much debate about the value and relevance of different types of research (eg qualitative versus quantitative) in relation to building such an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy. However, perhaps a much more pressing issue concerns how we engage members of the counselling and psychotherapy community in research. Especially, when there is good evidence to show that findings from research have only limited influence on the everyday practice of counsellors and psychotherapists - often because it does not adequately address the issues they encounter in their practice. One approach to engaging practitioners in research that has been employed successfully is the establishment of ‘practice research networks'. Essentially, a practice research network (PRN) provides a structure within which researchers, practitioners and other relevant stakeholders can collaborate on collecting data and carrying out research studies.This workshop will present the work of two PRNs at different stages of development as case studies around which to engage in reflection and discussion regarding the challenges and potential of the practice research network as a means of promoting and developing research that might contribute to the establishment of an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy. Dr Joe Armstrong from the University of Abertay will present the work of the recently established Scottish Voluntary Sector Counselling Practice Research Network and Amanda Hawkins, Senior Manager RNIB (Chair of BACP) and Mhairi Thurston, University of Abertay will present the work of the Vision Impairment Network for Counselling and Emotional Support (VINCE). The workshop will also provide opportunities for discussion in small groups and contributions from participants in larger plenary sessions.",
author = "Joe Armstrong and Amanda Hawkins and Mhairi Thurston and Alison Hood",
year = "2012",
month = "5",
day = "10",
language = "English",
note = "BACP's 18th Annual Research conference : Understanding counselling and psychotherapy: preferences, process and outcomes ; Conference date: 10-05-2012 Through 12-05-2012",

}

Armstrong, J, Hawkins, A, Thurston, M & Hood, A 2012, 'Practice research networks: promises, pitfalls and potential' Paper presented at BACP's 18th Annual Research conference , Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 10/05/12 - 12/05/12, .

Practice research networks : promises, pitfalls and potential. / Armstrong, Joe; Hawkins, Amanda; Thurston, Mhairi; Hood, Alison.

2012. Paper presented at BACP's 18th Annual Research conference , Edinburgh, United Kingdom.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Practice research networks

T2 - promises, pitfalls and potential

AU - Armstrong, Joe

AU - Hawkins, Amanda

AU - Thurston, Mhairi

AU - Hood, Alison

PY - 2012/5/10

Y1 - 2012/5/10

N2 - A critical issue facing the counselling and psychotherapy profession at present concerns the question of how to build a strong and externally-credible evidence base for its effectiveness. There is an emerging view that unless we address this question, counselling and psychotherapy approaches may be sidelined in favour of therapies with a much stronger base of research findings that support their effectiveness. Ultimately, a lack of an evidence base for the effectiveness of counselling and psychotherapy approaches may mean that they struggle to survive and be recognised as credible interventions for mental distress, particularly within public sector settings.But how can we go about building this evidence base? There is much debate about the value and relevance of different types of research (eg qualitative versus quantitative) in relation to building such an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy. However, perhaps a much more pressing issue concerns how we engage members of the counselling and psychotherapy community in research. Especially, when there is good evidence to show that findings from research have only limited influence on the everyday practice of counsellors and psychotherapists - often because it does not adequately address the issues they encounter in their practice. One approach to engaging practitioners in research that has been employed successfully is the establishment of ‘practice research networks'. Essentially, a practice research network (PRN) provides a structure within which researchers, practitioners and other relevant stakeholders can collaborate on collecting data and carrying out research studies.This workshop will present the work of two PRNs at different stages of development as case studies around which to engage in reflection and discussion regarding the challenges and potential of the practice research network as a means of promoting and developing research that might contribute to the establishment of an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy. Dr Joe Armstrong from the University of Abertay will present the work of the recently established Scottish Voluntary Sector Counselling Practice Research Network and Amanda Hawkins, Senior Manager RNIB (Chair of BACP) and Mhairi Thurston, University of Abertay will present the work of the Vision Impairment Network for Counselling and Emotional Support (VINCE). The workshop will also provide opportunities for discussion in small groups and contributions from participants in larger plenary sessions.

AB - A critical issue facing the counselling and psychotherapy profession at present concerns the question of how to build a strong and externally-credible evidence base for its effectiveness. There is an emerging view that unless we address this question, counselling and psychotherapy approaches may be sidelined in favour of therapies with a much stronger base of research findings that support their effectiveness. Ultimately, a lack of an evidence base for the effectiveness of counselling and psychotherapy approaches may mean that they struggle to survive and be recognised as credible interventions for mental distress, particularly within public sector settings.But how can we go about building this evidence base? There is much debate about the value and relevance of different types of research (eg qualitative versus quantitative) in relation to building such an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy. However, perhaps a much more pressing issue concerns how we engage members of the counselling and psychotherapy community in research. Especially, when there is good evidence to show that findings from research have only limited influence on the everyday practice of counsellors and psychotherapists - often because it does not adequately address the issues they encounter in their practice. One approach to engaging practitioners in research that has been employed successfully is the establishment of ‘practice research networks'. Essentially, a practice research network (PRN) provides a structure within which researchers, practitioners and other relevant stakeholders can collaborate on collecting data and carrying out research studies.This workshop will present the work of two PRNs at different stages of development as case studies around which to engage in reflection and discussion regarding the challenges and potential of the practice research network as a means of promoting and developing research that might contribute to the establishment of an evidence base for counselling and psychotherapy. Dr Joe Armstrong from the University of Abertay will present the work of the recently established Scottish Voluntary Sector Counselling Practice Research Network and Amanda Hawkins, Senior Manager RNIB (Chair of BACP) and Mhairi Thurston, University of Abertay will present the work of the Vision Impairment Network for Counselling and Emotional Support (VINCE). The workshop will also provide opportunities for discussion in small groups and contributions from participants in larger plenary sessions.

M3 - Paper

ER -

Armstrong J, Hawkins A, Thurston M, Hood A. Practice research networks: promises, pitfalls and potential. 2012. Paper presented at BACP's 18th Annual Research conference , Edinburgh, United Kingdom.