Tamarin mixed-species groups: an evaluation of a combined captive and field approach

Hannah M. Buchanan-Smith*, S. M. Hardie

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The geographical distributions of the tamarins Saguinus mystax, S. imperator and S. lahiatus do not overlap, but each of these species is sympatric with S. fuscicollis, and mixed-species associations are formed. One way to examine the costs and benefits of association is to compare mixed-species tamarin groups and single-species tamarin groups in the field. However, the stability and permanency of Saguinus associations mainly preclude such opportunities and comparisons between single- and mixed-species groups from different sites are confounded by a number of factors. However, predictions derived from field observations can be tested in captivity under controlled experimental conditions. In this paper, we evaluate the usefulness of testing hypotheses in captivity and describe an experimental study of vigilance in which the behaviour of single-species groups and mixed-species groups of S. fuscicollis weddelli and S. I. lahiatus was compared in order to determine the influence of each species on the other. The results demonstrate that the patterns of vigilance are both different and complementary. As such, they provide support for improved detection of predators as being one advantage of forming mixed-species groups. The discussion focuses on how the combined approach of systematic testing of hypotheses in captivity, together with field studies, can be employed to examine the advantages and disadvantages of Saguinus associations.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)272-286
Number of pages15
JournalFolia Primatologica
Volume68
Issue number3-5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1997
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Saguinus
Callitrichidae
captivity
geographical distribution
vigilance
testing
predators
prediction
evaluation
hypothesis testing
experimental study
predator

Cite this

@article{9b39dbe44d614ac2bc9eec1c568dffd3,
title = "Tamarin mixed-species groups: an evaluation of a combined captive and field approach",
abstract = "The geographical distributions of the tamarins Saguinus mystax, S. imperator and S. lahiatus do not overlap, but each of these species is sympatric with S. fuscicollis, and mixed-species associations are formed. One way to examine the costs and benefits of association is to compare mixed-species tamarin groups and single-species tamarin groups in the field. However, the stability and permanency of Saguinus associations mainly preclude such opportunities and comparisons between single- and mixed-species groups from different sites are confounded by a number of factors. However, predictions derived from field observations can be tested in captivity under controlled experimental conditions. In this paper, we evaluate the usefulness of testing hypotheses in captivity and describe an experimental study of vigilance in which the behaviour of single-species groups and mixed-species groups of S. fuscicollis weddelli and S. I. lahiatus was compared in order to determine the influence of each species on the other. The results demonstrate that the patterns of vigilance are both different and complementary. As such, they provide support for improved detection of predators as being one advantage of forming mixed-species groups. The discussion focuses on how the combined approach of systematic testing of hypotheses in captivity, together with field studies, can be employed to examine the advantages and disadvantages of Saguinus associations.",
author = "Buchanan-Smith, {Hannah M.} and Hardie, {S. M.}",
year = "1997",
doi = "10.1159/000157253",
language = "English",
volume = "68",
pages = "272--286",
journal = "Folia Primatologica",
issn = "0015-5713",
publisher = "S. Karger AG",
number = "3-5",

}

Tamarin mixed-species groups : an evaluation of a combined captive and field approach. / Buchanan-Smith, Hannah M.; Hardie, S. M.

In: Folia Primatologica, Vol. 68, No. 3-5, 1997, p. 272-286.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Tamarin mixed-species groups

T2 - an evaluation of a combined captive and field approach

AU - Buchanan-Smith, Hannah M.

AU - Hardie, S. M.

PY - 1997

Y1 - 1997

N2 - The geographical distributions of the tamarins Saguinus mystax, S. imperator and S. lahiatus do not overlap, but each of these species is sympatric with S. fuscicollis, and mixed-species associations are formed. One way to examine the costs and benefits of association is to compare mixed-species tamarin groups and single-species tamarin groups in the field. However, the stability and permanency of Saguinus associations mainly preclude such opportunities and comparisons between single- and mixed-species groups from different sites are confounded by a number of factors. However, predictions derived from field observations can be tested in captivity under controlled experimental conditions. In this paper, we evaluate the usefulness of testing hypotheses in captivity and describe an experimental study of vigilance in which the behaviour of single-species groups and mixed-species groups of S. fuscicollis weddelli and S. I. lahiatus was compared in order to determine the influence of each species on the other. The results demonstrate that the patterns of vigilance are both different and complementary. As such, they provide support for improved detection of predators as being one advantage of forming mixed-species groups. The discussion focuses on how the combined approach of systematic testing of hypotheses in captivity, together with field studies, can be employed to examine the advantages and disadvantages of Saguinus associations.

AB - The geographical distributions of the tamarins Saguinus mystax, S. imperator and S. lahiatus do not overlap, but each of these species is sympatric with S. fuscicollis, and mixed-species associations are formed. One way to examine the costs and benefits of association is to compare mixed-species tamarin groups and single-species tamarin groups in the field. However, the stability and permanency of Saguinus associations mainly preclude such opportunities and comparisons between single- and mixed-species groups from different sites are confounded by a number of factors. However, predictions derived from field observations can be tested in captivity under controlled experimental conditions. In this paper, we evaluate the usefulness of testing hypotheses in captivity and describe an experimental study of vigilance in which the behaviour of single-species groups and mixed-species groups of S. fuscicollis weddelli and S. I. lahiatus was compared in order to determine the influence of each species on the other. The results demonstrate that the patterns of vigilance are both different and complementary. As such, they provide support for improved detection of predators as being one advantage of forming mixed-species groups. The discussion focuses on how the combined approach of systematic testing of hypotheses in captivity, together with field studies, can be employed to examine the advantages and disadvantages of Saguinus associations.

U2 - 10.1159/000157253

DO - 10.1159/000157253

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0001726219

VL - 68

SP - 272

EP - 286

JO - Folia Primatologica

JF - Folia Primatologica

SN - 0015-5713

IS - 3-5

ER -